Celebrating good, clean, fair fish

Guest Contribution by Dave Adler

Every two years, farmers, chefs, fishers, food educators, and foodies from around the globe gather in Turin, Italy at an event called Terra Madre. Italy is the birthplace of the international Slow Food movement, and Terra Madre is its Mecca.

One of four exhibit rooms

The venue was enormous. There were 220,000 visitors. 1,000 exhibitors. Acres of charcuterie. This was a celebration of small-scale food on a scale that was anything but small- a small-scale event of Olympic proportions.

Over 2000 delegates from 130 countries gathered to learn about, talk about, cook, taste and celebrate food that is good, clean, and fair. Canada sent about 60 delegates and I was lucky enough to have been one of them. We were a motley crew of chefs, farmers, fisheries folks, managers, entrepreneurs, and food agitators.

So why was I there? Fish. Slow Fish International is a subset of Slow Food, and shares a similar mandate: to celebrate, promote, and protect food (fish) that is good, clean and fair. Representatives from 24 countries took on the weighty task of creating a Slow Fish Manifesto, and providing input for the United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)’s International Guidelines for Securing Sustainable Small-scale Fisheries.

We met every day, which was a challenge considering we were steps away from sampling oysters from Holland, foie gras from France, and prosciutto from every corner of Italy. Not to mention the pub that the Brits set up, and the Italian Enotecca, which boasted over 1200 types of wine. It’s a wonder anyone made it to any workshops at all.

Our conversations varied widely over the 5 days, but several key themes emerged:

The Clam Revolution is alive and well in Turin.

What do we mean by “small-scale”?  Similar to discussions at Tony Charles’ panel event held last month in Halifax, we had a hard time defining what “small-scale” means. We established that there is nothing “small” about small-scale fishing- it accounts for 90% of the global capture fisheries and other jobs associated with fish processing, distributing and marketing (half of which are held by women). We agreed on what it is not– it is not industrial. It is not destructive. It is not commodity based. We arrived at an understanding that “small-scale” is related to the degree to which the fishery was based in its community, and the nature of the post-harvest value chain. So it is possible to fish in a “small-scale” way with a large(er) boat, just as it is possible to carry out a large scale fishery in small boats. In the end, we agreed that the definition of ‘small-scale’ lies somewhere buried in the definition of ‘sustainable’, ‘community’, and ‘fair’.

What do we mean by fishing rights?  Are we talking about access rights to the fish themselves? Are we talking about property rights? Human rights? Management rights? Are we confusing rights with privileges?   What are the implications of privatization? Does privatization of fisheries lead to an obligatory forfeiture of wealth by those who can least afford it? Seth Macinko of the University of Rhode Island led some key discussions, and cautioned that when large, vertically integrated industrial fishing companies (or sovereign nations) use the term ‘fishing rights’, they may mean a very different thing than do proponents (and practitioners of) small-scale fishing.

What do we mean by value chain?  We focused on the key distinctions between a commodity based supply chain and a relationship based value chain. The former pushes as much product as possible to the market and competes on price, and is characterized by a lack of information flow between sections of the chain. A value chain happens in reverse- it starts with what consumers want (ie. fresh, fair fish), and then establishes relationships along a supply chain that allow this to happen.  A value chain does not compete on price, but rather on the integrity of the entire chain, the stories behind the members of the chain, and a free and honest flow of information between them. The value added by each member is also shared equitably.

The McConnell Foundation recently funded a series of regional value chain assessments across Canada. When Ecology Action Centre looked at the seafood value chain in Nova Scotia, the findings were clear: there is none. Nova Scotia’s seafood harvesters, regardless of how small-scale they are, have to work very hard to find a market for their product outside of the industrial supply chain. You can spend all day in a dory with a hand line jigging for cod, but at the end of the day, it will most likely end up in Boston mixed up with the fish the draggers bring in.

Burgeoning food agitators, Terra Madre

At Terra Madre, we came to a common understanding that regional value chains built of harvesters, buyers, processors, distributors, retailers, chefs, and consumers, are critical to the continued existence of small-scale fisheries. With no value chain to feed into, a ‘small-scale’ fisher is just feeding a large-scale commodity supply chain in a small boat. And then they tend to go out of business.

The power of Slow Food is in the understanding that the issues facing small-scale fisheries are the same challenges facing all small-scale food producers- whether they spend their days catching fish, jarring tomatoes, or extracting nectar from agave plants.  Terra Madre is a living testimony that small-scale food is anything but small. It is huge, and it begins with commitment from all of us to support, celebrate, and seek out food that is good, clean, and fair.

Dave Adler is the Community Supported Fisheries Coordinator at Ecology Action Centre. December 10th is International Terra Madre Day– How will you celebrate?


9 thoughts on “Celebrating good, clean, fair fish

  1. Great post. Thanks for sharing this. I appreciate the definitions that you’ve provided. I think it would be really interesting if there was a tool to analyze small supply chains and determine what’s missing (although I’m sure it’s intuitive to people in the chain). Seems like it would be useful for economic development organizations.

    • Thanks, Tammy. We just completed a value chain assessment of the seafood value chain in Nova Scotia. The approach is relatively straightforward- you start with the final price of a product at the retail or restaurant level, then track the product back through the chain to see who gets paid what for the value they add at step of the chain. The challenge is accessing the information, which is tricky (especially in the mainstream supply chain, where pricing information is rarely shared across the chain). I’d be happy to share the report with you. Send me an email: dadler@ecologyaction.ca

  2. Great post! I might put some food for thought out there on whether small-scale fisheries can be destructive. In my view such fisheries are better for the environment because 1) they can’t exert that much fishing effort and 2) they can use less destructive gears. But there still are destructive small-scale fisheries. In southeast Asia there are such community-based fisheries using dynamite and cyanide. And in the eastern Pacific, some artisanal fishermen operate using stow nets at the base of estuaries, which has huge bycatch and takes mostly sexually-immature species.

    • Excellent point, Mark. Its so important not to romanticize the small-scale- though they are generally more ‘sustainable’, there are certainly questions and problems, even in our local Nova Scotian inshore fisheries. Sounds like a blog post for the new year… 😉

  3. Pingback: Terra Madre 2012: Celebrating Good, Clean, Fair Fish / Célébrant le poisson bon, propre et juste | Slow Food Canada

  4. Pingback: Célébrant le poisson bon, propre et juste | Small Scales

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s